Would you as a blogger change your views on a subject if offered money?

Anoop Zombie
Anoop Zombie
from Bangalore
4 years ago

This could be a slight trigger question .. with so many companies willing to pay for a post from blogger like smorty etc .. this I feel is already happening and most of the time they are products that we really havent heard of ..

But the real question is, if you knew for a fact that a canon camera was better than its peer Nikon camera.. Would you write a super post for the Nikon Camera if money was on the table?

1-20
21-23
Replies 1 to 20 of 23 Ascending
Parv Kaushik
Parv Kaushik
from Lucknow, Noida
3 years ago

hmmm.... well depends upon the amount of money!! lolzzzz okk just kidding but i think theoritically we can say or think anything but its only when the actual real life thing happens that we know what we'll do!

Mainak
Mainak
from Kharagpur
3 years ago

@All those who say they won't change their opinion for money: I think it is really foolhardy on your part. If you liked a Nikon and were asked to endorse a Canon or vice versa, it wouldn't do any harm if you endorsed Canon although you liked Nikon.

The basic premise why most people don't wish to do that is because of the social incentives. People wish to come across at morally right human beings. This gives them a lot of leverage in the society. Changing their opinions often would make them lose their credibility.

But when the financial incentives outweigh the social/moral incentives like in the case of Canon/Nikon (atleast for me), one tends to accept money for writing a favourable post for the product.

It is a question of balancing the two.

 

 

 

Mathew
Mathew
from kottayam
3 years ago

Not a chance Smile

Rahi Vidya
Rahi Vidya
from Delhi
3 years ago

man thats not the way things happen. why will someone pay u if he/she knows that u don't rate their product well and going to write better about the competition. its better than not writing.

Subhayan Mukerjee
from Pilani
3 years ago

was jus jokin' man ...

Subhayan Mukerjee
Subhayan Mukerjee
from Pilani
3 years ago

never ... i would persuade the person to pay for my views without changing it Laughing

Rahi Vidya
Rahi Vidya
from Delhi
3 years ago

Umm tricky question... but maybe yes I will write about a product if they are offering me good money. don't get me wrong. i m not that much greedy for money, but also I will not ignore ati hui lakshmi.  I have supporting reasons:

All of us will agree to this that blog is a media like newspapers and TV channels. Have you ever heard a newspaper refusing to advertise a product just because it doesn't go in sync with its philosophy. In the classifieds, a large number of the ads are from obscene or fake advertisers. Or refusing to advertsise or PR some product because it earlier glorified its competitor. No. So why us?

Agreed that a blog is more like a personal diary where you post things that you personally feel for. I have a solution. I saw this being used by some blogger, i don't remember who. After talking skies about a product, the blogger wrote a P.S; it's a paid post.

So if you are fearing that your readers will be astonished at your change in philosophy, just do this. Or better create a new category for paid posts.

Tell me will you want to do paid posts now.

@Renie: do they really pay that much of money for blogging. get me some of those projects man. I am ready to do.

Hariharan S
Hariharan S
from Chennai
3 years ago

@Anoop: No, I will not change my opinion. Instead i will ask for money from the company, who-s product i like. So that makes me true to myself. Write what you think and get money from the guy who benefits from it. Thats my idea.

Rajnish Kumar
Rajnish Kumar
from Bangalore
3 years ago

There is this story abou two friends who were discussing their sex life.

first one says - you know somethin' that famous actres xyz has agreed to sleep with me.

The second one is surprised - what are you talking about/I can't believe it.

First one gets back - There is just one problem.She is asking for 5 million dollars for a night and I have offered 500 dollars.Lets see  we are negotiating ...

I will put it more bluntly - how many of us will not write a great post for a Nikon camera if we are offered $ 2000 for a single post ?A camera is a camera is a camera..right ???

It all depends - if it is about a camera I would most certainly find out all the best things I can about my nikon and write a great review but if the subject is more intense I won't budge for any amout of dope.

NT Balanarayan
NT Balanarayan
from Bangalore
3 years ago

No way will I glorigy a product if I think it's not good. But if the product is good, I don't see a reason why one shouldn't. However, if anyone is writing a paid post, they should definitely make it clear right in the beginning. So that people don't get deceived

Deepak Shenoy
Deepak Shenoy
from NCR, Delhi
3 years ago

The Nikon may still have fantastic things about it - so I might say those, and in the end mention that I like the Canon better, and very importantly, that Nikon is paying me for this endorsement, so take it as you please. Of course if I said that Nikon would be unhappy, but that's the way the cookie crumbles.

If I felt passionately about something, I wouldn't change my opinion. You couldn't get me to write a single favourable thing about most Unit Linked Insurance Products, they are all scams, one way or the other. But certain term plans rock - so I might diss an insurance company for one product and praise them for another. Yet, if they decided to pay me, I might still endorse the products I like, but will mention that I'm paid by them in that blog post. 

I have had some requests to endorse products, but after I mention this small point they usually go away. 

Shankar
Shankar
from Chennai
3 years ago

no way..

aniruddha pathak
aniruddha pathak
from mumbai
3 years ago

nope never :)

Sanjay
Sanjay
from Hyderabad
3 years ago

no! I wont. As far as I am concerned I blog because I want to write what ever I feel like. Money may not change my opinion. http://har****has.blogspot.com

KHUSHI
KHUSHI
from Mumbai
3 years ago

Never...!!!! Yell

Pawan Maruvada
Pawan Maruvada
from Visakhapatnam
3 years ago

Blogging is actually the synonymn for writings which are un biased straight from the heart of the writer.

Blogging nowadays are more trustworthy than newspapers.

i guess people will be attracted towards money but eminent and truthful bloggers will never sell their work in favorof one company fot the sake of people!

It's a BIG fat NO!

We read in the news about how people change parties for money...not to speak of blogging about products as you mentioned.

Integrity and money both have value. The catch is that we 'assign' them value. And we choose accordingly.

It could also be that the blogger is writing about it and not endorsing it !?

Venkata Vinay @ Affirmative Thinking

Anoop Zombie
Anoop Zombie
from Bangalore
4 years ago

@ Everyone : Great to have a feedback from you guys on this!!

On the lighter side.. I have my doubts as to whether bloggers are going to honest about this on the forum LOL.. but theres really nothing to be judged here .. Blogging is taking shape in India and its good to know the blogosphere a little better

 

Karthik
Karthik
from New Delhi
4 years ago

Well, I used to use smorty before, but did not post anything that I didn't know about or against my thoughts, like your Nikon example. But you know what, after sometime it becomes like you spamming your own blog Wink

Renie Ravin
Renie Ravin
from Chennai
4 years ago

@Jamshed - that's pretty much the IndiBlogger philosophy - keeping true to the blogosphere. If not, every blog loses it's value and what we write about becomes irrelevant.

Jamshed Wadia
Jamshed Wadia
from Singapore
4 years ago

@ Anoop : I was hearing the founder of payperpost some weeks back on Blog radio and he mentioned that they are doing really well. i like the concept and i think companies are better off using their services rather than using Ghost bloggers. I completely believe in being transparent and honest on the blogosphere.


1-20
21-23