The IndiBlogger forum is now a read-only archive. Every public discussion is still here to read, but new topics and replies are closed.
You find a blog you like, or even you want that reader to come to your blog and read. How would you, as a blogger, expect a comment on your blog to be? 
How do you comment? Would a "good job" or "nice work" suffice? 
Your views please...
(If thread already present before, please feel free to redirect me. I searched as farback as I could in the archives.)
Replies 1 to 7 of 7
commenting comes from heart. like when I read a post, the feeling of how it was and comment words start pouring in. some posts, need deliberate squeeze of mind to extract some suitable words.
I do justice to those nice job, somments in my reply, discreet thanks, but those who take pains to write long words, i too reciprocate same way.
but, one has to laud everyone. someone is short of time and one or two words from a man of less words is more than something.
Yes PL, I know.. I usually write atleast a sentence with something to indicate I've read the post.. but it does call out for some attention when a comment comes for a serious post saying "good job"
I think it should be read, and then comment, be it a paragraph, or two or three words?
hey Leo, a thread on the same topic does exist. Since am on mobile, cant direct you there. But you should be able to find it out ;)
@Hemal, too tired to manually hunt it out. If its there, once you come on to your system, can you please put the link to that in your comment, and I'll peruse that Soc can remove this thread then.
try searching on google the following -''site:indiblogger.in/forum comments and ethics'' without quotes
try searching on google the following -''site:indiblogger.in/forum comments and ethics'' without quotes. I got these search results.
google.com/m?q=site%3Aindiblogger.in%2Fforum+comments+and+ethics&client=ms-opera-mini&channel=new
Forget it na Hemal!
I remember one thread, let me search..... here, check this link-
@DS haha, but why?
Feeling Lazy, who will search!
You did, Good:)
@DS lol.. IndiHero ho kuch toh sharam karo 
LOL @ Arti :D
Have to be responsible :) :P
@Hemal, still too lazy anyways, that might be too far back. we can continue it here.
Let me confess first, I am a very lazy commentator. I rarely do comment, even though I visit many blogs. But obviously when I do comment I comment genuinely, like I did today on 2 of your posts...
And who does not love comments, I do too...
+10 for honesty :)
Thanks abhi:)
Yes I saw Thanks DS. Even I love comments, but sometimes, it feels like it's forced in somehow! So asked.
Yikes. 
I didn't mean yours two comments today. In general I was telling. (Just in case).
Thank your stars that you explained and gave that 2nd reply. I was about to have an outburst :P
Treat others as you would like them to treat you - that's my motto as far as commenting goes.. and I like to either leave thoughtful comments after reading the post or prefer not to leave my mark at all... but one/two words definitely don't do it for me :)
I do not visit many blogs, but yes I write comments on posts which I find interesting and worth commenting. Also I try to visit the blogs of people who mention their url while commenting.
Positive comments can act as great motivational tools for bloggers.
We are in the same boat abhi:)
lol :P
I also give my URL in the comment, because some people do come back through them they might be busy to go back through profile at times, and have mentioned that the URL does help them.
Positive comments can be very helpful. I agree!
yup they are great incentives for bloggers :)
Most of my comments are just two words , but i mean it . Won't comment for the sake of commenting .
Yes, there are some commenters who mean the two words, Dhiraj but if the blog you go on is new to you and you go on with two words only, the blogger at times doesn't get where to move further from his post. No feedback.. Hence I felt two words to be at times forced. No offence to you or those well-meaning bloggers like you