Skip to content

Plagiarised content

The IndiBlogger forum is now a read-only archive. Every public discussion is still here to read, but new topics and replies are closed.

Back to the opening post

Replies 21 to 28 of 28

Fairy Princess
from Delhi |

Ok....here is the story. Have a field day now/

http://community.babycenter.com/post/a23660497/marriage-_a_must_read_found_on_fb

Animesh
from Mumbai |

OK, read both posts now. Had not read Ankit's post till now.

The fact is that this story is a very old one. This may be doing rounds on FB today, but it is older than FB itself! So, obviusly who shares it on FB saying his/her own is also lieng. But, anyway that's not the question here. The question here is about the intention of Ankit. Though he has said that he did not know about this story being already published, believing him or not is on people.

As TF said, it's like getting inspired from the famous Rabbit and Tortoise story. Do you call it plagiarized? You may, you may not. I would once again request to get in touch with the blogger personally before putting a gun onto him/her. Someone's reputation is at stake here.

Sfurti Juztamom
from Mumbai |

Ok I have noting against the blogger personally...but as per me this is what happened....

"I found a post of someone else through someone else (Doen't matter if it was published or not), tweaked it, put it on my blog, claimed it was my work (Not even put a caption that it can be inspired)....people found out, questioned my intent....I apologised"

Its good that the blogger has apologised...good for him....and what action Indiblog takes, their decision..... but if you are saying....it was okay to copy because he was ignorant the work was published, I am really not getting the point...really??

But like Pankti....now I am out of this discussion obviously my line of thinking is very different from others!!!

Animesh
from Mumbai |

Just a little correction to what you said: 

"I found a post of someone else through someone else (Doen't matter if it was published or not),

In this case, the writer did not know that this was a post. He was narrated a story by a friend and he posted it. It's your decision to be out of this discussion which I think is the easiest thing to do. But then I have to think twice before writing every post. If I write based on some discussion with someone, do I write a disclaimer everytime that this is based on a discussion with so and so and that it might have been post eralier, too?

it was okay to copy because he was ignorant the work was published

As far as I undestand, the word copying can be used only if someone has got an inspiration from some post. In this case, when one was not aware that there has been any post of this sort and truly believed what his friend said, how can it be copy? 

Accusing someone of plagiarism without knowing his side of story, then expecting an action to be taken against him and then leaving the discussion half-way, is that OK?

Fairy Princess
from Delhi |

I still stand by my beliefs that this is called plagiarism (as would ANY editor), but if we are going to give a benefit of doubt here, who am I to say anything? I have said enough and I have even given enough evidence to prove my standing.  My case rests here.

Shaumik Daityari
from New Delhi |

The problem with facebook is that its search SUCKS. Secondly, finding the author of that FB story is impossible (unless use crawlers of the level that Google use and that too would guarantee the first post, not the author necessarily)

I can try a few Google searches to try and find a link to the "original" story, but I don't think it's gonna be easy.

I think we should stop disscusing the plagiarism issue until we find that story and give the author a chance to say what he thinks.

Fairy Princess
from Delhi |

Shaumik, I have given the link to the story.

Stephen
from Raleigh |

Pankti/Sfurti - You ask your friend for ideas for a story. They narrate you a story which intrigues you. You then decide to write a story based on what your friend told you. And then one day you find that the story that you have written has been doing rounds on Facebook.com - shared and liked by lots of people and posted and emailed as forwarded mails. Then you find a reader on your blog who says that they had seen your article somewhere on Facebook.com and accuses you as a plagiarist. Step on Ankit's shoes and tell me clearly - would you still feel the same the blog reader told you or would you say that you had sought inspiration from what your friend narrated you( Read inspiration).

Even I am against plagiarism. There are several 100's of stories being liked and shared in facebook and coincidentally if one of your story is similar to that ...would you like being called a plagiarist. I appreciate Ankit that he has apologised and even backed out of this contest after accused of this. This is disappointing and sad to be frank! IF he knew that this story was on facebook and despite of knowing it he had written, then I would say that it was wrong. But here the case is different. He has ONLY heard the story from his friend and doesn't even knows about the existence of this story on Social media. Its sad it all happened quickly without thorough investigation.

Animesh
from Mumbai |

Stephen, the key here is "thorough investigation".

Even if I believe that Ankit did it intentionally, he is far behind from Sourav Pandey when it comes to plagiarism. And people are free to read IB blog how they had handled the situation. It was not made public before his side of story was known. All posts in questions were checked and even after that he was given a chance to apologize via that blog post. 

TF Carthick
from Bangalore |

I was just going through the thread again. Suddenly I noticed something. You are asking them to step on Ankit's shoes, which is exactly what you don't want them to do I guess. (Guess you meant stepping into his shoes. But stepping on his shoeswould mean just the opposite)

Madhu Bhardwaj
from NOIDA |

Yes @TF. Absolutely correct. I was thinking what someone was thinking when he asked that we step 'on' his shoes.

Shaumik Daityari
from New Delhi |
Animesh
from Mumbai |

Can someone please tell me now who is the original author of this story?

Shaumik Daityari
from New Delhi |

don't think it's possible to trace it!

TF Carthick
from Bangalore |

One apect we must keep in mind is blog-o-sphere is still quite unstructured and informal and works in some ways like an extension of forwarding mails to friends and posting statuses on facebook. So clearly the rules are not defined as to what constitutes plagiarism and what does not. Mostly things work by social consensus - a more of a mobocracy. If lot of people feel something is plagiarism, it is . If not, it isn't.

But things are changing. These kind of lucrative contests are becoming more popular. Revenues from ad sense are probably going up. So in time more well defined norms need to come in for blogging, especially the more lucrative kind of blogging and in all likelihood has to align with the norms of traiditonal publishing and journalism. So in that context Pankti's comments are valuable and it is time all serious bloggers start re-evaulating their content with this lens before posting.

Animesh
from Mumbai |

TF, not everything which has similarity can be termed as plagiarized. I remember reading somewhere long ago, that everything question has been answered, everything has been written as the world started thousands of years ago. Do we have anything called original now?

In my opinion, plagoiarism should be linked to the intent.

TF Carthick
from Bangalore |

Animesh - These kind of arguments are meaningless. That is the reason we have laws and rule books to have everyone on same page whether we agree or not. And blog-o-sphere as such has no rule book. So from that angle anything is acceptable in blog-o-sphere. 

I can extend your argument and say even theft is not wrong. Everything on this earth is nature's bounty. Humans have started putting walls and boundaries and claiming things as their's and their descendants'. There is no justification for a man born with nothing to call his own to respect these unfair walls and boundaries. But then if he does not, police will kick his ass. So he has to. I would say it is not fair. But that is how the world is.

Animesh
from Mumbai |

There can be no law for blog-o-sphere as there is no government.

Fairy Princess
from Delhi |

@TF, nature's bounty?!...that's good one....LaughingLaughingLaughing

TF Carthick
from Bangalore |

Animesh - Possibly in future we may have a bloggers' guild formulating law. Till then, it is going to be mobocracy. People are going to get together on Facebook and lynch whoever they think is a plagiarist. That is why I generally avoid all these plagiarism witch hunts on facebook as it is very much a grey area with no clear lines drawn.

Anunoy Samanta
from Bardhaman |

Undecided this cul-de-sac investigation stole my afternoon nap.... Ahhh Yell

TF Carthick
from Bangalore |

By the way I noticed, the ending is different in Ankit's post. The difference is so significant that the entire punch in the original is lost.