The IndiBlogger forum is now a read-only archive. Every public discussion is still here to read, but new topics and replies are closed.
Replies 181 to 197 of 197
sorry, my mistake, the 'Indi-harper' team; thanks 'The Fool'. They gave us a big opporunity, accepted my idea, I cannot forget that :)
I am glad now mine was rejected. But who swlected the ideas by the way. DOES Harper official ly accept they read them even. I DOUBT.
One masterpiece struggling author had pasted some pages of his manuscript such that he would know if his manuscript was read or not, and sent to publishing house. when it was returned back he knew it wasn't even opened.
what abt the selected 10 entries...were they read or not?
Why would they have to read it. Anyways millions of readers are there to read them later on.
u mean they were randomly selected?? like ...inni mini maina mo ...or inky pinky ponky father had donkey.. 
I think the they won't reveal which one was used. That is their secret recipe to pull out great stories from a large pile.
They could have actually used a more ingenious scheme. Like assigning serial numbers to the shortlisted ideas and then running a simple random number generator to choose the final 10. It would have been more formal that way. 
What about random numbers from atmospheric noise? : http://www.random.org/ 
where is the winners list??? can someone help me out
The winners list is on the home page of GetPublished - http://www.indiblogger.in/getpublished/
Can anyone even find the get published forum post that stated that 50 winners would be chosen? Have they wiped their slate clean?
@Chaitanya - Its there in the email they sent across after we got shortlisted for the 2nd round.
Got it, thanks!
Heartiest Congratulations to the winners :)
Congrats to women! :)
...and I take this opportunity to share my review of Yashodhara Lal's novel.
http://passey.info/2012/10/gud-mawrning-to-read-n-recycle-review-of-just-married-please-excuse/
Gud Mawrning to read-n-recycle. Review of ‘Just Married: Please Excuse’
Dude, please speak up man.. your idea was rejected at first, then later after protest it came up on list. How come a harper venture come up with such lousy mistake.
It is not allowed to share blog links here Mr Passey. And I think you have been here long enough to know the rules of the forum!
happy 5th anniversary 
... A must opportunity to grab...
Hello,
Are we free to submit the rejected entries elsewhere to other publications? Has there been any communication on this issue? If not, would someone from the Indi-HC team please clarify? Many thanks.
Thank y'all Indibloggers also for the kind messages/congrats.
I think this by default, at least that's what happens in other short story contests. They cannot keep the copyrights for the rejected materials. Authors are free to submit it elsewhere or post in any other sites.
Thank you, Prasanna for responding. But I'd still like it spelt out in black and white from IB-HC. Many contests specify that the entries written cannot be posted/submitted elsewhere for a specific period of time and/or without the consent of the organisers. I cannot recall anything about copyrights or exclusivity being among the rules, so want to be completely sure.
Congratulations to the winners. Please bring this back in 2013.
I am ready to avail this opportunity now, I wasn't a blogger last year
Repeating the query I, and some other finalists may also, have. Are we free to submit the rejected entries elsewhere? Would really appreciate an answer- Renie Ravin, Yashodhara Lal, and HC. Thanks!
Further to what Nilanjana has written, I think the entries and previews should now be take out, right? Indiblogger... await your reply.
Congratulations to all the winners once again :) I really want to read the final book!
Hey Nilanjana,
I just received an email from Indiblogger and we are free to publish the entries else where. Below is the text that I received.. I am just copy-pasting it here for reference :)
***********************
As you may know by now, the final list of authors for Get Published has been announced, and we're sorry to say that you're not one of them. We thank you for participating in this edition, for all your hard work, and we hope to see you again when we come up with the next book by Indian bloggers!
We realize that you have many questions about the contest, and we hope the answers below are helpful.
Who judged the contest?The stories were solely judged by the editorial team at Harper Collins, with several of their senior editors involved.
Why weren't any male authors chosen?There were no pre-set rules with regards to the gender of the authors. Not unlike a music album, a compilation of short stories needs to come together as a package, which can be digested from start to finish without any jarring deviations from the overall theme or writing style. As it happened, these ten stories fit together the best - all of them being written by female authors was purely a coincidence!
Now that my story was not chosen, can I publish it elsewhere?Yes, you may publish your story elsewhere.
When can I read the final list of selected stories?The selected stories are by no means complete; each of the selected authors will now work with writers and editors of Harper Collins to get their stories ready for publishing, which may take several months. We'll keep you updated on the progress!
http://www.indiblogger.in/getpublished/
Keep blogging,
The IndiBlogger Team
**************************
Okay, now that we all have received this mail which clearly cites that we are not bound to any legal agreement that deters us from publishing our stories somewhere else, quite some air of ambiguity has subsided. I was wondering that since a substantial chunk of indibloggers would be publishing the rejected stories on their own blogs, is it possible to have one single unorthodox indi-forum where these indibloggers are allowed to post links to the short storie(s) that they eventually published on their respective blogs ? This would help in bringing all these 240 rejected but highly opulent stories under one single roof and would make it easier for each one to get acquainted with the story writing skills which all of us bring together cumulatively. I know it's pretty much against the rules of the forum but I'm just asking if we could consider such a thing. And in case this is not possible, can we have a new indivine submission entry that tags not only "stories" but stories that supposedly enjoyed being a part of the final race. Just for thought.
I came to know that all the selected ones were female bloggers only after reading the mail.
Instead of looking at winners, why don't we look at losers? Maybe men and women will be in equal ratio there.
Thank you, Amita! Much obliged to you for copy pasting! :)
Hi is there any update on this? I'm one of the winners and havent received any communication from the Harper Collins or Indiblogger team in the last 6 months atleast. Please revert asap.
See the comments by Anoop on this http://www.indiblogger.in/forum/topic.php?id=16942 thread.